[silent_jonny]

Bo was clearly the best. Carrie so-so. And Vonzell was a mess, IMO.

I don't think that one judge should pick one song for one performer--it leaves the door wide-open for sabotage. Instead, all three judges should unanimously choose one song for one performer. That seems fairest to me.

Great scorecard, btw :)

[bootless]

Song sabotage:

Remember Clay Aiken being saddled with Don McLean's "Vincent"?