Replies

I think their post is BS. First of all the black contestants have not been eliminated back to back, and second Hall and Oates were in the audience though they weren't judges.

I think AI is trying to vary the events year to year so that people can't anticipate what will happen. I do think the themes this year have been very lame and suck. I'd like to see more versatile themes. Perhaps a rock week, and a swing week (sorry Paula, that would be swing music, not swapping), you could have a country week, a rap week etc, but this 90's week followed by a 60's week, followed by a 70's dance tune week really goes nowhere and doesn't really challenge them at all, imho.

Simon at one time or another has claimed each was better than the others, one week its Carrie, another week its Bo. If Simon dislikes any of them I think it is Scott. Simon doesn't like overweight people, that was very obvious from the try outs.