Personally, I thought Bo should go even before his arrest info came out. IMO, he's dull, he's limited, he's not an exciting performer. He seems beige to me, a pale imitation of more talented singers. There are hundreds of guys like Bo in LA, playing around town at smaller clubs, some even playing for handouts on Venice Beach.
The very young kids, tomorrow's audience, are probably voting for Anthony, who seems to have enough talent for professional trainers and coaches to work with. He could become a competent singer of songs in his range, which is not a bad range. And he's cute. He could be featured in a Disney movie perhaps.
Vonzelle has the fire to take her to stardom, a strong though uneven voice, but also needs professional training.
Carrie is strictly Country.
Scott? Fat Ruben looked much worse on stage, IMO, but had a better voice. With months at a health spa and the right handlers, Scott could turn pro, though stardom seems out of his reach.
If I were a judge, especially one who had a financial interest in the careers of the winners, I'd want to keep Anthony and Vonzelle around til the end. They're engaging and seem to have talent enough to develope, encourage, and further.
Thanks for your post. Your assessment is pretty good. Next week is definately going to be interesting.