I just went to votefortheworst.com, and at the bottom of the page it has a visitor count. So far only 34000 or so visitors have been to the site. There is no way that small number of people can swing such a huge vote. Maybe there really just are some people who either feel sorry for him or genuinely think he's good.
That site likes to claim it is responsible, but I seriously doubt they are having much effect. They took credit for keeping John Stevens in last season, but he had a quirky quality that people liked. So far this season, they have backed Mikayla, Constantine & Janay...so their record sucks.....they only got behind Scott in the past 2 weeks.
As the field gets narrowed down, it will be harder for votefortheworst to make an impact. Someone will get Constantines votes. That's X amount that vftw has to make up. Can they? I think each week it will get harder for them to have an effect.
Given the absolute crap that passes for music now a days ... I wouldn't be surprised