They should leave Scott in the competition.
Because he's NEVER going to win it.
Nice voice - but NO charisma. He's just mediocre to me.
Nadia - sizzling.
Carrie - classic country.
Bo - hubba hubba yum, yum!
BTW...I think Simon Cowell had it right with Carrie in her opening audition, when he said he was amazed that a shining country star hadn't shown in the first three Idol competitions. He told her from the get-go, she had star quality in the country genre.
And Simon knows his stuff. (The other two judges? To much crapology from them IMO, and they are too interested in making the contestants feel good. Simon knows what will sell)
I understand what you are saying about Carrie's stage presence...but I think that she could easily be moulded (with the proper team around her).
I think Simon (in particular) likes that about her. She's compliant. Record companies like that. They can make her a cross-over country/pop artist very easily - and without much argument - very easily.
I'd say she's up there at the top three.
Carrie/Nadia/Bo - my top three.
I really like Carrie.
I fancy Bo.
But, I think Nadia should win!
Because he's NEVER going to win it.
Nice voice - but NO charisma. He's just mediocre to me.
I agree, except it may not be up to Scott whether or not he stays in the competition. Usually when a skeleton falls out of a contestant's closet, they dismiss them immediately. Unless AI knew about his arrest beforehand.
When do you see this week's AI in Ireland?