[silent_jonny]

In other words, Carrie's in-store sales were lower than Fantasia's last year.

And that's counting digital downloads too? Ouch.

[Wolfstar]

And that's counting digital downloads too? Ouch.

Actually, when digital sales are added to Carrie's numbers, she's a little higher than Fantasia last year. Carrie's total physical and digital first-week sales were 168,634. Fantasia's total, physical only (digital weren't added last year) was 142,000. Carrie is below Fantasia if digital sales are subtracted from her total.