Her first performance (audition)
and very last ("Thank you, America!")
were the only two times she seemed real, IMO
Apparently America agrees with you,
or her win would translate into better sales.
We'll know as the numbers come in, but I think she's going to debut with a modest hit. However, I think it won't have any staying power.
The target release for both first albums by Carrie and Bo is thus Fall. Personally, I wish they and the producers would not rush, but take their time to find quality material that suits each of their styles. We are, unfortunately, a disposable society. Yesterday's star becomes tomorrow's has-been all too quickly unless they can make money for the producers. Remember how hot Justin Guarini was after he finished 2nd in the first season? I honestly don't want to see that happen to either Carrie or Bo.