Above average are the words I'd use. Nothing catchy to Claptons playing. Jus aping a few Robert Johnson riffs (in a sterile way, mind you) and a couple of Buddy Guy fills and wallah, you have Clapton.
EVH is a true shredder and can play his ass off, but as far as mucisianship and artistry it just isn't there.
What do you think of James Lee Hooker's sides collected on "Alone" years ago?
Burnin' Hell is probably one of the most haunting riffs I ever heard.