[HairOfTheDog]

3) No Mouth of Sauron, no Easterlings and other human armies meeting the West at the Black Gates. No despair by the Fellowship that Frodo is dead(mithril shirt)

At the black gate, when Aragorn turns back to see Gandalf and the others, his eyes are red with tears before he says... "For Frodo". I think we will see the Mithryl shirt in the extended.

Sauron--What's with the "eye" looking at the tower collapsing around it? I liked the great cry that arose from the tower in the book.

But the moment that was really captured ~just~ like I imagined was the eye suddenly turning it's focus to Mount Doom.... snapping over like "WHAAAT? Dan.... remember us talking about this way back in 2002? PJ got that right. I am glad Sauron remained an eye.... that is all we ever knew of him in our mind's eye from the book, and to turn him into a physical form would have caught more people wrong. I liked the eye kinda nervously looking around as it went down.

[BibChr]

1. I thought the exact same thing in re. "For Frodo." So it must be right!

2. Not only do I remember our conversation, but I thought of you and your remark in that very connection. "Whaaaat?!!"

Dan

[BibChr]

Dang, I wish this thread wasn't in the ghetto. We'd have fifty times the feedback; we'd have trolls, too, but more conversation would be more fun.

)c8

Dan