senators are no more than at-large politicians with extended terms . . .
Let’s put that statement into proper perspective.
Senators by virtue of the 17th are popularly elected “Representatives” who’s term according to the Constitution is two years not six. That fact alone is sufficient for States to nullify the 17th Amendment.
There is also some Woodrow Wilson progressive history behind the year 1913 in which the 17th was ratified and a few other things done to qualify the year as one of the worst in American history.
If your State happens to be one of many supported by tax revenue from other States through the Federal spread the wealth around program, you might consider that status in the context of the welfare system sustainability, and how long other states should be willing to support your welfare status.
The paragraph directly above is brought to you courtesy of the income tax system that allows citizens of States, to bypass State government and send tax money directly to the Federal government neutering state governments local control of their people. The income tax system is just one more unconstitutional result from the year 1913.
Yes, 1913 was a very bad year under a very bad President.