Let’s keep that performance in perspective, he got his team to 8-8 which in that division was good enough for a 3 way tie by beating mostly teams that finished under 500 in his SECOND season in which he fumbled the ball more times than he threw TDs while his defense was giving 2 less TDs a game than they were before him.
Tebow has earned the pot shots, he’s a second year QB with atrocious career statistics: completion % - 47.3, yards per pass - 6.8, TDs - 17, INTs - 9, sacks - 39, fumbles - 14. Yeah he was showing some improvement in his 6 game win streak, but then came the season ending 3 game losing streak where-in he completed a TOTAL of 30 passes. He’s a nice guy, but he’s not a good QB, and anybody that would keep him over Peyton Manning is an idiot.
I wouldn't advocate keeping him over Peyton Manning, but I might advocate keeping them both, and having Manning mentor Tebow.
Cool numbers, now mention the fact he helped get his team into the second round of the playoffs.