My job is done. You're arguing against yourself now, because you clearly denied these were the facts for Minor. Remember?? You challenged anyone to find a sentence from Minor saying these were the facts. It's okay to admit you were wrong, and because you were, the rest of your argument fails.
The stuff about Chester Arthur is nonsense. Arthur left office in 1881. Wong Kim Ark wasn't argued until 17 years later. The Supreme Court did not wait around that many years for the U.S. government to appeal a citizenship case so they could try to repair Arthur's legacy. He died 12 years before the case was heard. Who the hell would have cared ... Arthur's natural-born children??? And again, the Wong Kim Ark case does NOT help Arthur because upheld Minor's definition of natural-born citizen, which would have excluded Arthur.re arguing against yourself now, because you clearly denied these were the facts for Minor. Remember?? You challenged anyone to find a sentence from Minor saying these were the facts. It/i
I agree with your assesment. Also are we sure Rummychick isn’t a member of the Fogbow???
Idiocy. I have never said that Minor’s parents weren’t American citizens. I have asked you to point to the exact sentence that says they are American citizens. The court only IMPLIES it. And that is pertinent.
When a court has to address citizenship that is germane to the case they address in detail the citizenship of the parents. Minor never discusses the parents because her citizenship was not in dispute. That is because the lower case was thrown out on a demurrer.
This is a finer point. I really didn’t expect you to understand it.
Chester Arthur did not leave office in 1881 as you claim. He did appoint Horace Gray.
Chester Arthur was not eligible to be President if you use what you claim is the only definition of an NBC.
The could have had repercussions to Horace Gray.
Of course, if Leo is your hero you should read what he has to see about Gray and Arthur.
You really hack me off because either you are an idiot or are being obtuse on purpose.
Let me repeat.
I said REPEATEDLY that Minor’s citizenship was a FACT NOT IN DISPUTE.
In describing Minor, it would be perfectly appropriate to say that she was born in the US to American Citizens. It’s a fact in the case NOT IN DISPUTE. That doesn’t mean the only definition of NBC is the most restrictive.
In fact, if you had bothered to read the lower court case in Ark you will see a less restrictive definition that the court says is controlling on them unless and until SCOTUS gives a different definition that is not part of Dictum.
Oh, and yeah SCOTUS AFFIRMED the lower court without exception.