[Amityschild]

Divided Loyalties, Obama’s Eligibility Problem, PART 1

[Always Right]

I still want to see a certified copy of his birth certificate. Something fishy is going on there too.

[arthurus]

It is all a waste of time and effort. Whatever is true, if anything disabling is brought to light Congress will take care of it within 48 hours of the determination that is disabling by passing whatever is necessary to declare him a “natural born Citizen.” And if that happens maybe the Crats will go about calling each other “Citizen!” which is sort of the English for the French word that became “Comrade!” farther east.

[Amityschild]

Ping!

[Calpernia]

Well written! Bump

Emphasis:

There should be a paper trail in US State and Federal and Foreign Government Records to prove, or disprove, my views. In fact, there must be and if there is not then it follows that somebody has removed the trail. If they have there has been a criminal conspiracy.

[Gatún(CraigIsaMangoTreeLawyer)]

“Senator John McCain was born in the Panama Canal Zone…”

This is where I stopped reading.

If the author got that wrong, what else did he/she get wrong?

[Calpernia]

Go read this whole thing!

[Calpernia]

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/2051691/posts
Obama’s eligibility problem UPDATE

[pissant]

Good stuff

[David]

I have a number of comments regarding Professor Benjamin's articles--the first of which I have read carefully; the second of which I am partially through.

And the articles are excellent well thought out and comprehensive documents.

But there is one major boot in Part II that I cannot pass without calling your attention to it: "IF:

He was born in Vancouver, British Columbia, or in any other part of the Dominion of Canada, on August 4th 1961, or at any other date, he was born a Canadian Citizen under The Canadian Citizenship Act of 1946. Due to the age of his mother he would NOT have been a US Citizen under the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952, until the passage of 8 U.S.C. 1401, Sec. 301 (g) at which point he became a Citizen by Law as of November 14, 1986."

That's clearly wrong--if he was born in Canada, he would never become a US Citizen as a result of passage of 8 USC Sec. 1401(g) (Sec. 301(g) of the INA of 1952).

The provision was added in 1986 by Section 12 of Public Law 99-653. Section 23(d) of Pub. L. 99-653, provided that: "The amendment made by section 12 shall apply to persons born on or after November 14, 1986."

Obama was born in 1961, long before November 14, 1986, and as a matter of law I think it is reasonably clear this provision does not ever apply to him.

As a legal proposition, the law appears clear that if he was born in Canada, or in Kenya, he is not a US Citizen at all unless or until he is naturalized as provided by law.

[browardchad]

In “Dreams from my Father”, Obama says specifically that he lived with his step-father in Indonesia for five years

Does anyone have a page citation for that?

I can't find it in the book.