You are way out of line. The agreement was made to enhance discussion and to make it a more pleasant environment for all concerned - not just those who agreed to it. In addition, ALS did agree to the agreement with the exception of going around calling people trolls due to his belief that it was uncivil to do so. Thirdly, this agreement is about civility and a call for not talking to someone because in the future they may be disruptive is uncivil and wrong according to the agreement. Any charges made by those who signed up have to be supported. Since you are calling for his being silenced ahead of his doing anything chargeable, it is you who is breaking the agreement, not ALS.
Lastly, the purpose of this agreement was to stop this constant bickering and letting people discuss the subject at hand. Discuss the subject, if the agrieved do not complain, it is not your business to do so in their behalf.