Replies

I don't know if there's anything to the roofer or not. It is strange that Ed Smart says there is something to him but the police said there isn't. Though Ed said there's something to it he had never bothered telling us before and still doesn't plan to release any information for another few weeks. It makes me wonder what else Ed and the police might know that they haven't released to the public. I would like to hear a description of the roofer, if he is appr. 5-8 to 5-10, late 30s, athletic, thick dark hair with wide sideburns, red, green & blue tatoo, etc. I'd also like to know where Ed heard about this roofer living in a homeless shelter and how he happened to hire him for one day's work on his home.

Good, you also think it is strange that Ed comes up with the roofer angle but the police say there's nothing to it.

Ed, whether he knows it or not, isn't helping the case with these off-the-wall ideas. John Walsh may have all the sympathy in the world for the Smarts, pushing this roofer as a suspect - or he may be more interested in raising his ratings.

An already confused case gets more confused, and one has to wonder why those closest to Elizabeth would want to do that?