I do not recall seeing a photograph from the punkster that was the “same” as Orly's image. I posted BP2’s comparison of two similar images, which are the only ones I am aware of.
The punkster could easily have staged his/her photo to look as close as possible to Orly's image after reproducing Orly's image as closely as possible to create a hoax punk.
If you post a link to a punkster image that is in fact literally the same as Orly's (without the schmutz as you claim), I would be very interested and it could well shift the relative probabilities that I currently assign to the two images.