[ClearCase_guy]

One thing about the Star Wars movies that always struck we was that Yoda was really wrong about everything. If you look for it, it's remarkable how little Yoda get's right. And the entire Jedi Council couldn't see the Sith in front of their noses. They were all blinded by their arrogance.

I don't think Lucas expolored that very much (that I know of) but I think it was apparent if you look for it.

Rowling, I would say, sees Dumbledore in a similar way, and I think she actively explores it. Yes, he's good. Yes, he's the most powerful wizard in the world. But he's flawed. The world has problems, and some of those problems are the fault of the great Dumbledore.

I think Rowling dives into deep water here, and does a fine job.

[TalonDJ]

Rowling, I would say, sees Dumbledore in a similar way, and I think she actively explores it. Yes, he's good. Yes, he's the most powerful wizard in the world. But he's flawed. The world has problems, and some of those problems are the fault of the great Dumbledore.

I like him much more as a character now and am much more impressed with JK's writing after this book. The thing is I can't stand that 'I am an all mysterious powerful cryptic wizard' act. Come on, what kind of scumbag sends kids into danger that he could take care of himself quite easily. All through the other books he seemed too scheming. Now it makes much more sense and fits into his personality and flaws. Not that I like the person any more, but as a well written cohesive character I like him better.