So, basically what you are saying is that no observation in the fossil record would convince you that your idea is not correct. This again, therefore, is not a scientific theory. If I am wrong, then please tell me what observation would make you conclude that you are wrong.
The unfalsifiability factor applies to all parties concerned, since none were present to observe the fossil record as it was laid down. The plausibility factor weighs in favor of creationists because they have a written record handed down through history that attests to a catastrophic event that could very well have resulted in the creation of the fossil record.