Skip to comments.Five Lone Stars. Mess with Texas? Sure. Divide it into five states.
Posted on 08/22/2004 9:19:07 PM PDT by John Jorsett
What would you say if we told you we have a way to add as many as eight new Republican senators to Congress? We could also add eight right-leaning votes to the Electoral College. It's simple, it's fun, and it's perfectly constitutional: Texas should divide itself into five states.
Article IV, Section 3 of the U.S. Constitution says that new states may be created out of existing ones, but only with the consent of "the States concerned as well as of the Congress."
These days, a partisan Congress would never agree to a Texas carve-up, since any resulting new states would surely be politically conservative. But Congress need not take any action at all today: It granted its consent to Texas's potential subdivision 159 years ago. This made sense, as those had been the terms that Texas, a sovereign nation at the time, had negotiated for entering the Union. One provision of the 1845 Joint Resolution for Annexing Texas, passed by Congress and signed into law by President John Tyler, reads as follows:
"New States, of convenient size, not exceeding four in number, in addition to said State of Texas, and having sufficient population, may hereafter, by the consent of said State, be formed out of the territory thereof, which shall be entitled to admission under the provisions of the federal constitution."
(Excerpt) Read more at opinionjournal.com ...
Touch my state and you die. I will ZOT anyone who tries to mess up Texas!!
Well, at least y'all seem to be moving in the "right" direction. A GOP pickup of five counties, if I count right (San Joaquin, Stanislaus, Merced, Ventura, and San Berdoo).
I actually did have that honor.
Oh, you mean give it back to Mexico?
Explaining the politics... we did buy that land from Russia.
As to not giving them more representation in Congress...
Texas has a population of 20,851,820
Alaska has a population of 626,932
There was a war. The Republic of Texas won independence.
They were all Texas at one point... That is until we got rid of 'em and kept the true part...
Oops, I see I was looking at those color associations backwards. Yes a divided Alaska would get more electoral votes (right now they have 3). Rhode Island has 4 (with a population over 1million). Washington DC has 3 (with a population of 600k).
There would possibly be even MORE electoral votes in the region (each state would get at least 1).
Tennessee has 96 counties. By makding each county a state, we would have 192 senators and 96 congressional representatives. Then other states could follow suit and end up with over 1000 senators and the county by county red and blue map could be reflected in the makeup of the senate and house....
In all seriousness, where would such gerrymandering end?
The provision for up to 5 states was a condition of adding Texas to the United States. This was because they thought that such a land mass may not be accurately represented.
But it would add 4 DemocRATS and 4 Republicans to the senate. It would not change the partizan margin, but it would increase the number of sentate votes required to achieve a cloture vote.
There was a war. The Republic of Texas won independence.
I'm not the one who suggested that it go back to it's original state.
I had to laugh at the little square you put in Tompkins County...Ithaca, Ny (LOL)>
1. of,or for the people. Ok.
2. believng/practicing social equality. All created equal or take from me to give to you equality?
3.charateristic of the democratic party. I'm serious. That's what it says
This is what is already happening and why we would even debate dividing this great state. Many of our leaders have chosen to ignore that we are a republic and decided to embrace democracy. So, STX would go democatic if left to stand alone. El Paso and Brownsville would be the new Calif and NY IMO. Best if we stay one and united, I think.
For those who missed the previous thread on this: the "divide the state without a congressional vote" gambit ONLY works for Texas, because only Texas's admission resolution arguably permits subdivision without additional congressional approval. According to this argument (which, though not beyond all cavil, is probably right), Texas can turn itself into as many as five states anytime that it feels the urge. Any would-be "state-lets" from other states would have to be "admitted by Congress into this Union" under Article IV, section 3, clause 1 of the Constitution. (Why is Texas different? Because the admission resolution of 1845 already granted the necessary congressional approval to further division.)
Maybe instead of splitting it up we should take back all of the original.
I'm with you! :^D
He started by flying to San Francisco and worked east from there. Going to a very large church, he began taking photographs and notes. He spotted a golden telephone on the vestibule wall and was intrigued by a sign which read: "$10,000 a minute."
Seeking out the Pastor he asked about the phone and the sign. The Pastor explained that the golden phone was, in fact, a direct line to Heaven and if he paid the price he could talk directly to God. The man thanked the Pastor and continued on his way.
As he continued to visit churches in Seattle, San Diego, Chicago, Greensboro, Tampa and all around the United States, he found more phones with the same sign and got the same answer from each Pastor.
Finally, he arrived in Texas. Upon entering a church in Dallas, behold, he saw the usual golden telephone. But THIS time, the sign read: "Calls: 25 cents." Fascinated, he asked to talk to the Pastor.
"Reverend, I have been in cities all across the country and in each church I have found this golden telephone. I have been told it is a direct line to Heaven and that I could talk to God, but, in the other churches the cost was $10,000 a minute. Your sign reads 25 cents. Why?"
The Pastor, smiling benignly, replied, "Son, you're in Texas now... It's a local call."
We need to fix the problems of the United States by electing the RIGHT people for the job. We need to get the truth out to the American people, the kind of truth like the Swift Boat Vets have recently been spreading. We need to do everything we can to counter the lies and dishonest ramblings of media outlets like the New York Times and ABC. We need to UNIFY as Americans and go after evil - ALL kinds of evil, including Socialism, Communism, Islamic fascism, and this festering disease of indifference that has seemed to take over most of Europe.
Texas is fine the way it is, standing tall, proud, strong and free. Let's make the rest of the country that way too.
Over my cold dead body. ;-)
Sorry, make that 6 Republican Senators and 2 Democrats from South Texas along the Rio Grande. That region went heavy for Gore in 2000 and will certainly go that way for eFing.
Darnit! That only makes it a net gain of 4...
"Original state" means nothing. "Mexico" is a nation that has not even 200 years of independence.
ROFL ! That is a CLASSIC ! I love it ! :^D
I wish they would break up New York too.
I'm not sure why you included Putnam and Dutchess Counties as part of the "Peoples Republic of New York." I don't think that a Democratic presidential candidate has ever won Dutchess County, including FDR, who lived in the County (Hyde Park). Putnam County is also heavily republican. On the other hand, neither Erie County nor Monroe County have a place in a "Free New York."
One more time _ I didn't say it _ I was quoting someone.
We keep waiting for the San Andreas fault to do that for us!
I doubt if there a lawyer or judge anywhere, regardless of his or her political orientation, who would agree with the opinion that any action of Texas voters could carve up that state in contravention of the U.S. Constitution. Our organic law declares its supremacy. No law of any sort can be enforced when found to contravene the provisions of the U.S. Constitution. A mere resolution of Congress, whether unilateral or joint, does not even have the force of law and, even if it did, it would violate the Supremacy Clause and thus would be a nullity.
I'd still be a Texan, so who cares whether it's one state or 5... and we'd still be better than the rest of y'all..
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.