Posted on 06/16/2017 4:42:20 AM PDT by SJackson
When Israel waged a defensive military operation against Hamas in Gaza in the summer of 2014, the international community and the Obama administration alike were quick to offer condemnations, with then-State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki calling Israeli attacks on civilian facilities appalling. But if youre still wondering what really went down during Operation Protective Edge, you might want to listen to Ateeq al-Falahi, the secretary general of the United Arab Emirates-based Red Crescent.
Hamas, al-Falahi said in a recent interview, deliberately launched rockets from a UAE-run field hospital in Gaza in the hope of provoking Israel to respond by shelling the facility. This shows (Hamass) wicked intentions and how they scarified us, Al-Falahi said. They always claim the enemy targets humanitarian envoys, but the betrayal came from them.
Betrayal may be too soft a term: as if Hamass double war crime wasnt bad enoughfiring from a humanitarian facility, and then murderously using wounded innocents as human shields for propaganda purposesthe terrorist organization controlling Gaza had a final surprise up its sleeve as the conflict drew to a close and al-Falahi and his men prepared to leave. When he and his team were making their way out of Gaza, al-Falahi recounted, Hamas had contacted extremist militias in Sinai and ordered them to prepare for jihad. As we stopped at a grocery store to buy something to eat, al-Falahi recalled, they started shooting at us. The Red Crescent volunteers fled, only to discover that Hamass associates in Sinai had planted landmines down the road, hoping to inflict the greatest damage possible.
What hurts, al-Falahi restated his theme, is that the betrayal came from our own people. Muslims fighting Muslims, who were giving humanitarian aid to Muslims.
You can stop paying attention to the story right here, and argue triumphantly, as so many of us pro-Israel loudmouths so often do, that once again Israels hasbara talking point turned out to be completely true while its enemies accusations were lies. Youre free to chant I told you so all you want, and proclaim that al-Falahis account should hardly surprise anyone who was paying attention at the time, considering that we had independent footage of Hamas doing much the same thing, even though most news organizations refused to report the truth for fear of losing their precious access to terrorists and the terrified civilians they held hostage. Youre also free to argue that the timing of these accusations is suspicious, given the recent diplomatic flare-up between the UAE and Hamass sponsor Qatar. But all that is largely beside the point; there are deeper insights to be gleaned here, and they have much to teach us about just how morally bankrupt the global conversation about Israel has become.
When a conflict breaks out, decent people feel sick. Their first impulse is to stop the violence, and protect innocent lives. So it is perfectly understandable that, watching shellings on CNN and debates at the UN and John Kerry and his spokespeople being solemnly appalled, even proudly Jewish viewers may conclude that all of this criticism of Israel cant mean nothing. As the saying goes, where theres smoke, there must also be fire.
But heres why its highly unlikely that there is ever any fire under the smoke: Israel, for all of its flaws and its faults, is an open and democratic society. Its armed forces obey rules of engagement that are more restrictive than those under which American or European forces operate. Israel also grants the local and the international media largely unfettered access to its cities and to battlefields. Israel, therefore, has virtually no incentive to lie about easily verifiable matters of fact that occur in public while operating under a global microscope. You may have little respect for the current government in Jerusalem, and you may have your qualms about some or all of its policies, but, honestly, no one is that stupid.
Which leaves us with Hamas. Why is the group blatantly falsifying facts? The answer here is simple, too: Because they can get away with it, year after year after year. And they can get away with it because their arguments about Jewish perfidy and bloodlust were never based on facts to begin with.
What the terrorist organization offered the world in Gaza in 2014 was a version of the story contained in its founding charter, which is only the latest chapter in a very old story: The Jews are sucking our blood. Deliver some version of this libelous tale, and no one rushes to examine the evidence. After all, anti-Semitic atrocity stories dont need evidence to back them up; theyre part of a larger conspiracy theory, in which the Jews are responsible for the worlds misfortunes.
Why do Western governments and news organizations endorse this insane medieval garbage? Well, thats also easy to explain: If the people you are trying to strike deals with believe that a malignant sea-serpent is their main foe in life, who are you to disabuse them of that idea, however idiotic? Western governments and news organizations are happy to at least pay lip service to vile and nonsensical anti-Semitic canards to ease their commercial relationships with unfree societies whose leaders repeatedly blame the Jews for their perpetual failures. The price of not doing so might be high. The price of doing so is guaranteed to be low, especially when you dress up the old anti-Semitism in fancier garb and call it anti-Zionism.
After all, what are the Israelis going to do about the fact that a State Department spokesperson blames Israel for appalling attacks on civilianswhen there is no shortage of video (and spy satellite) footage showing that the actual war crimes were committed by Hamas, which is an actual terrorist organization? Sever ties with Washington, D.C.? Ban Reuters or the AP for collaborating with a gang of Islamist terrorists who hold two million people hostage to their insanity? Of course not.
But that doesnt mean that theres nothing we Jews can do. We canand mustresist this idiocy whenever it pops up, which is depressingly often. It doesnt matter if you think Bibi Netanyahu is a villain or a saint. It doesnt even matter if you define yourself as a Zionist. As a Jew, whenever demonic lies are told about other Jews, lies that are blatantly false and poisonous and malicious, you have a personal responsibility to fight these lies. Because, ultimately, these lies are not just about Israeltheyre about you.
If you'd like to be on or off, please FR mail me.
..................
“Even”????
How about “especially “?
Fixed it
If Europe and the US were to stop all aid and comfort to this bigoted war of annihilation, how much longer could it last? I’ve come to think of Hamas as hired guns, rather than perpetrators.
That was my first thought too. Even when they’re on CNN? Ha! Anything CNN puts out should be considered anti-American enemy propaganda. Anything and everything - I wouldn’t even trust them for weather updates.
I agree with the others... it’s not “even,” it’s “especially” when it’s on CNN.
I remember when the Palestinians had kidnapped that fox news reporter Steve Centanni.
At one point they had put out video showing he was unharmed. He was in someone’s house and the wife was there in the background doing chores or what not.
To say the “families” of terrorists are innocent is absurd.
It matters not that Israel makes superhuman efforts to spare civilians lives while the Arabs always used Human Shields as they are true cowards.
It also doesn't matter that Arabs viciously kill Arabs everyday in the Middle East. This, we call Middle Eastern Peace. The Arabs kill Combatants, noncombatants, it matters very little.
When Israel is attacked, we call the Middle Eastern War.
The Arabs will always accuse the Israelis of all the evils that they themselves perpetrate on each other and on the Israelis (and West).
They are congenital lairs and always have been. I refer to the words spoken by T.E. Lawrence in the 1962 classic, “Lawrence of Arabia”:
T.E. Lawrence: Sherif Ali, so long as the Arabs fight tribe against tribe, so long will they be a little people, a silly people, greedy, barbarous, and cruel as you are.
What he said in 1916-17 holds true today.
I had the same thought, ESPECIALLY.
I’m a big fan of disproportionate response. Need more stickers to cover the “coexist” stickers on cars around here.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.