Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Legal analyses show that Russian-German gas pipeline may be illegal.
Warsaw Business Journal ^ | 3rd October 2005

Posted on 10/03/2005 2:17:10 PM PDT by lizol

click here to read article


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-6061-8081-85 next last
To: REactor

As for the German-Polish relations, both sides have to work on it to maintain the good mood between us. Since Poland and the eastern parts of my country joined the league of free nations, there was conflict between us, and there shouldn´t be one. As long as we are free, democratic and righteous states, we will have good relations. I can sort-of guarantee you that Germany will be such a country. It is on you to do the same for Poland. :-) I have no worries about that.

I don´t know what the purpose of this pipeline on the German side is, if not monetary interests. I hope that there´ll be some more explanation.


61 posted on 10/07/2005 7:44:30 AM PDT by Michael81Dus
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 60 | View Replies]

To: Michael81Dus
It is on you to do the same for Poland. :-)

I'm afraid you require the impossible from me. No one can guarantee the future. It is diplomats' and politicians' job to be aware of this more than other people.

I don´t know what the purpose of this pipeline on the German side is, if not monetary interests.

I suspect what the reasons on the part of Germany may be: exactly the same as Polish. Germany thinks that one day Poland may use the "gas blackmail" against Germany. In this case it prefers to be dependent on Russia rather than on Poland. I don't blame Germans, I think that the core of the problem is in the German-Polish relations. If they were really good Schroder would never think of striking deal with Russia to the detriment of Poland's strategic interests. The problem is that Germans trust Russia more than they trust Poland. Why it so remains a mystery to me. Maybe you tell me?

62 posted on 10/07/2005 8:08:32 AM PDT by REactor
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 61 | View Replies]

To: REactor

Well, Poland does not border Russia, so Belarus could play a role. Also, Schröder and Putin are friends - I don´t know why. It is double standard to criticize the Iraq war while not criticizing the war in Chechnya.

On a last note, I think it is every citizens task to prevent evil regimes, so I´ll stay with my "it´s your job!" But as I said, I have no worries about your success.


63 posted on 10/07/2005 9:12:20 AM PDT by Michael81Dus
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 62 | View Replies]

To: jb6
...$20 billion or so euros...

I'm not trying to be picky, just informative.

The glyph for the Euro, €, can be displayed by using the html code:

€

(The semicolon at the end is required.)

I'll go and add this note to the HTML Sandbox thread - if it's not already there.

64 posted on 10/07/2005 9:38:57 AM PDT by delacoert
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: Michael81Dus
Well, Poland does not border Russia,

Poland does border Russia, remember about the enclave.

so Belarus could play a role.

Belarus is a puppet state. There is a deal between Lukashenko and Putin, Luka is the president with full internal power but he must play nicely with Moscow, what means that his foreign policy is strictly controlled by Kremlin. Remember that Belarus is 100% dependent from Russian gas and oil. They don’t like this Baltic project as well but they refuse to comment these plans cause they received such orders from the east.

It is double standard to criticize the Iraq war while not criticizing the war in Chechnya.

You are right this is amusing. How about the Greens? Looks like they betrayed their ideals as well.

65 posted on 10/07/2005 2:28:58 PM PDT by Lukasz
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 63 | View Replies]

To: Michael81Dus
If we talking about this pipeline. I will wrote something about the Balts and their problem. Today gas deliveries to Lithuania are safe because through their lands flows gas to the Kaliningrad enclave. This is their only guarantee of safety. New under-Baltic project is planned with branch to the Russian enclave, of course bypassing Lithuania. So it is another opportunity for theoretical blackmail.

I’m curious how hypocrites from European commission want to secure energetic security of the Baltic countries. Poland at least may cooperate with other countries and build other pipe in the future. But who the hell will build the pipeline to three little states? It would be totally unprofitable project.
66 posted on 10/07/2005 2:44:25 PM PDT by Lukasz
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 63 | View Replies]

To: delacoert
Thanks, but I develop and program web based apps for a living (at least for another 3 months). I didn't realize the € was part of the standard ASCII character set, since FR does not display the extended ASCII character set, which allows for such things as the Cyrillic alphabet to be displayed.
67 posted on 10/07/2005 3:58:21 PM PDT by jb6 (The Atheist/Pagan mind, a quandary wrapped in egoism and served with a side order of self importance)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 64 | View Replies]

To: Lukasz; Michael81Dus
So it is another opportunity for theoretical blackmail.

As opposed to the blackmail by the Balts or Poles on the passage of gas to market, while they tack on their fees. It's not about you not being able to buy gas, you'll still be able to buy it, its about you not getting tranfer tariffs and watching one of the few positive incomes for a socialist, bankrupt, unemployed economy vanish.

68 posted on 10/07/2005 4:26:23 PM PDT by jb6 (The Atheist/Pagan mind, a quandary wrapped in egoism and served with a side order of self importance)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 66 | View Replies]

To: Michael81Dus

Cutting out the middleman and the cost tacked on is a typical capitalist move.


69 posted on 10/07/2005 4:28:48 PM PDT by jb6 (The Atheist/Pagan mind, a quandary wrapped in egoism and served with a side order of self importance)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 61 | View Replies]

To: sergey1973
He is a Canadian citizen so it could be an International scandal if Russian authorities did that.

Only if he enjoys diplomatic immunity. Otherwise, every sovereign country is completely within its rights to detain anyone who is suspected of a crime within its territory, foreigner or not.

70 posted on 10/07/2005 5:52:21 PM PDT by tarator
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 32 | View Replies]

To: jb6
It's not about you not being able to buy gas, you'll still be able to buy it, its about you not getting tranfer tariffs and watching one of the few positive incomes for a socialist, bankrupt, unemployed economy vanish.

Please provide legal documents or other reliable sources to confirm Polish government makes money of the transfer via Polish territory. If you can't - then stop barking about things you have no idea about.
71 posted on 10/11/2005 2:17:39 AM PDT by twinself
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 68 | View Replies]

To: twinself
Please provide legal documents or other reliable sources to confirm Polish government makes money of the transfer via Polish territory.

By and far, one of the stupidest statements you've made. So you don't make money? Then you're a bunch of first rate fools. Either that or you are so full of it, the Martians can smell it. Which is it?

You'd best tell Deutsche Welle they're wrong too and all the experts, since you angels don't charge for having gas move over your land. What a laugh....don't let anyone tell you you aren't funny.

Putin to meet Schröder in Berlin in Sept

Russian President Vladimir Putin will hold talks with German Chancellor Gerhard Schröder in Berlin on September 8 just days before a general election in Germany, Schröder's spokesman said on Friday. Bela Anda said the two leaders, who are close friends, would discuss "economic ties, especially cooperation in the energy field, but will also talk about international issues." The Financial Times Deutschland on Friday reported that a contract for the construction of the so-called Ost-See gas pipeline was expected to be signed during the visit. The pipeline is a joint project between Germany's Eon Ruhrgas and Russia's Gasprom to feed Russian gas directly to Germany through the Baltic Sea from 2010. The project is controversial in Poland and the Ukraine because they stand to loose transfer fees. Schröder faces an uphill battle to hold on to his post in early elections on September 18, with polls indicating he is likely to be unseated by conservative opposition leader Angela Merkel.

72 posted on 10/11/2005 6:31:44 PM PDT by jb6 (The Atheist/Pagan mind, a quandary wrapped in egoism and served with a side order of self importance)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 71 | View Replies]

To: twinself; GarySpFc; Romanov; RusIvan
If you can't - then stop barking about things you have no idea about.

You should take your own advice, since you're showing your "knowledge".

From ISN: International Relations and Security Network Part of the problem is that Poland and the Baltic states currently receive transit fees from Russia's state-owned energy giant Gazprom for allowing its pipelines to cross their territory on their way to the western European market

73 posted on 10/11/2005 6:43:35 PM PDT by jb6 (The Atheist/Pagan mind, a quandary wrapped in egoism and served with a side order of self importance)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 71 | View Replies]

To: jb6; Lukasz; lizol; Grzegorz 246; Tailgunner Joe; macel
Leave your funny propaganda aside and let our Russian friends comment on that fact. They know that Polish commies signed a deal allowing Russian gas go via Polish territor for practically for free(!). It's only these brain-washed useful geniuses, Russian wannabes like you who still can't get it. Well, it seems that it a is hopeless case :)

See:

Point.1 Art.5 Agreement between the government of Russian Federation on building gas pipeline system for transit of Russian gas via territory of Republic of Poland and delivery of Russian gas to the Republic of Poland. August 25, 1993.

Provided you can find access to the agreement..:)

Now let's do some maths.

$2,74 for transit of 1.000m3 of gas over 100 km - average price Gazprom owned Wintershall pays for using Romanian company (ROMGAZ) infrastructure in Germany. Russian Gazprom in EU will charge 3,3 USD. According to PGNiG vice president Polish prices are MUCH lower than $1 for transit of 1.000m3 of gas over 100 km. Therefore I took the safe estimate of 0,50 cents.

682 km from Kondratki to Gorzyn, Polish transit route

5 billion m3 - amount Polish side uses per year from Jamal 1, but agreement appendix from 2003 states that Poland will receive (and pay for 9 billion m3 of gas)

9.000.000.000 x 6,82 x 2,74 : 1000 = 168.181.200 USD per year

9.000.000.000 x 6,82 x 0,5 : 1000 = 30.690.000 USD per year (in theory payed by Gazprom to Polish-Russian company Europolgaz. Shares of Europolgaz split 48% PGNiG, 48% Gazprom, 4% Bartimpex and other minor Russian spies agendas). Europolgaz owes Gazprom 1 billion dollars for an investment credit in Jamal 1. What's more as a non profitable company for several years it didn't pay any taxes to Polish budget.

Instead of echoing propaganda sources it's good to use your brain from time to time. Doesn't hurt.
74 posted on 10/12/2005 2:12:24 AM PDT by twinself
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 72 | View Replies]

To: twinself

You are 100%, overwhelming corruption among politicians, they are in Gazprom’s pockets. They are selling national interests for pennies. As you know these facts that you provided here it is just a little part of the “business”.


75 posted on 10/12/2005 2:54:07 AM PDT by Lukasz
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 74 | View Replies]

To: Lukasz

I mean "you are 100% correct"


76 posted on 10/12/2005 2:55:12 AM PDT by Lukasz
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 75 | View Replies]

To: jb6
The project is controversial in Poland and the Ukraine because they stand to loose transfer fees.

To make it funnier Ukraine doesn't get any fees at all, simply keeping 1/3 of the gas transported (up to 30 billion m3 a year). Here's congratulations on profound competence of your DW sexperts.
77 posted on 10/12/2005 4:16:58 AM PDT by twinself
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 72 | View Replies]

To: twinself; GarySpFc; RusIvan
To make it funnier Ukraine doesn't get any fees at all, simply keeping 1/3 of the gas transported (up to 30 billion m3 a year).

Oh, the 1/3rd isn't payment? Gads, I guess you seriously take us here for fools but the only one who is is you for trying to push such stupidity. Fine, how about we measure what the worth of that 1/3rd is, I'd bet it's well over $50 billion, such a small 'fee'.

78 posted on 10/12/2005 2:19:06 PM PDT by jb6 (The Atheist/Pagan mind, a quandary wrapped in egoism and served with a side order of self importance)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 77 | View Replies]

To: twinself
They know that Polish commies signed a deal allowing Russian gas go via Polish territor for practically for free(!). It's only these brain-washed useful geniuses, Russian wannabes like you who still can't get it. Well, it seems that it a is hopeless case :)

So you are a liar (what's new?) and there was a few by your own admission (never mind my articles and common sense) you just don't feel like it's big enough so you use the leftist technique of trying to deny there even is one. Well, isn't that a surprise? /sarcasm

79 posted on 10/12/2005 2:21:13 PM PDT by jb6 (The Atheist/Pagan mind, a quandary wrapped in egoism and served with a side order of self importance)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 74 | View Replies]

To: twinself
Lets see, you stated:

Please provide legal documents or other reliable sources to confirm Polish government makes money of the transfer via Polish territory. If you can't - then stop barking about things you have no idea about.

71 posted on 10/11/2005 2:17:39 AM PDT by twinself

But now that I've proved there is a fee, you change your argument to show that its in your opinion so small that its not a fee, but yet it is a fee, just not to your liking. Wow, how circular that logic and how you're trying to change it now that you've been proven a liar.

Here's some advice, renegotiate but just keep in mind that you might renegotiate yourself out of everything and that is capitalism. Outside of set contracts presently in existance, no one has to sell you anything, even if you can't survive without it.

80 posted on 10/12/2005 2:24:48 PM PDT by jb6 (The Atheist/Pagan mind, a quandary wrapped in egoism and served with a side order of self importance)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 74 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-6061-8081-85 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson