The U.S. Has More Guns, But Russia Has More Murders

NPR ^ | 21 Sept 2013 | Corey Flintoff and James Glynn

[Theoria]

The U.S. and Russia have been taking lots of jabs at each other.

Russian President Vladimir Putin criticized President Obama's plan for a military strike in Syria, and the Russian leader then denounced American "exceptionalism" in a biting op-ed in The New York Times.

Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., fired back Thursday with his own op-ed in the Russian paper Pravda, entitled, "Russia Deserves Better Than Putin."

Even Monday's shooting at the Navy Yard in Washington, in which a gunmen killed 12 people, has become part of the feud.

Alexei Pushkov, the chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee in Russia's parliament, used the shooting to mock the United States as it was happening.

"A new shootout at Navy headquarters in Washington — a lone gunman and seven corpses. Nobody's even surprised anymore. A clear confirmation of American exceptionalism," Puskoy tweeted.

But while Pushkov sneers at U.S. gun laws, how do the stats look in Russia?

According to Gunpolicy.org, Russians have far fewer guns than Americans — and far more homicides.

There are fewer than 13 million firearms in circulation in Russia, compared with an estimated 300 million in the United States. That works out to about 9 guns per 100 people in Russia and closed to 100 guns per 100 people in America.

The most recent homicide statistics for Russia show that there were 21,603 killings in 2009.

According to the FBI, the United States had 13,636 homicides in 2009 with a population that is more than twice as large. More than 80 percent of those killings were gun-related.

It's difficult to make a direct comparison of gun homicides in the two countries because Russia doesn't break down its murder statistics.

Russian Gun Laws

Russia has tough gun laws on the books. It's illegal for Russian citizens to own automatic and semi-automatic guns. It's possible to apply for a handgun or shotgun license, though citizens are required to provide reasons such as hunting or target shooting.

Applicants face strict background checks, including criminal history, a full psychological evaluation and a medical exam. They must pass a test on firearm laws and safety.

Each weapon is then registered by the police during a home visit. Police take bullet patterns, test bullets and cartridges so bullets can be matched if the gun is used in a crime. A license lasts five years, after which applicants must go through the whole process again.

In spite of these laws, the country does have periodic mass shootings by people thought to be mentally ill.

Last November, after a five-day drinking binge, 30-year-old lawyer Dmitry Vinogradov posted a message online referring to humanity as "compost."

Shortly after, he walked into the Moscow pharmaceutical company where he worked and opened fire, killing six colleagues and critically injuring another. He was jailed for life last week.

Move To Ease Gun Laws

The Right to Bear Arms, a Moscow-based organization that has more than 5,000 members, is trying to make guns more easily available in Russia.

"Our citizens are deprived of normal tools of self-defense, and that plays an important role in public safety," Maria Butina, the group's 24-year-old founder, told The Moscow News.

But she has a long way to go in convincing the public. A poll by the Levada Center in 2011 showed that 80 percent of Russians are opposed to easing existing gun laws.

[TomGuy]

Chicago is trying really hard to make up the deficit.

[Yo-Yo]

There are fewer than 13 million legally owned firearms in circulation in Russia, compared with an estimated 300 million in the United States.

There, fixed it.

[BenLurkin]

IBTFAP

[cunning_fish]

>>>It’s illegal for Russian citizens to own automatic and semi-automatic guns.<<<

Bullcrap. 60% civilian shotguns and rifles in Russia are built around AK.
Saiga, Vepr etc. Prohibited in US - an SVD semi-auto milspec sniper rifle sells as a civilian ‘Tiger’ rifle in Russia.
Bolt-action guns are very rare there, mostly imports.

[UnwashedPeasant]

And Russia has no Amish people.

[dfwgator]

And Russia has no Amish people.

But they do have Uzbeks.

[elcid1970]

I was deployed to Uzbekistan. They seemed OK to me & the women are beautiful, many of them. The most laid back Muslims you will ever see (they like their vodka). I know Russians regard Uzbeks as nearly subhuman but is any group in Russia as completely evil as Chechens?

Google “Karshi draft riots 1916”. Our base was outside that city.

[Charles Martel]

Bullcrap. 60% civilian shotguns and rifles in Russia are built around AK. Saiga, Vepr etc. Prohibited in US - an SVD semi-auto milspec sniper rifle sells as a civilian ‘Tiger’ rifle in Russia.

Agreed, that sounds incorrect. Semi-auto rifles are legal for Russian civilians to own, though I believe you've got to first own a shotgun for five years (one license renewal interval) before they'll grant the rifle permit. Full-auto is not legal (though the substantial underworld doesn't seem to care).

[cunning_fish]

BTW, Russian homicides are way too different comparing to US.
95% are domestic or drunk disputes between siblings.
Street homicide, armed robbery leading to a death of a victim are state-level emergencies. I mean if a gas station in Pacific region was robbed at gunpoint it makes headlines in Moscow 5000 miles away.
I’m not telling you can walk in a bad neighborhood at night without any risk but the chance to get mugged is about 10 times lower than in a good old US. A chance to get killed in process is close to zero.