A Manifest Heretic Can Neither Become nor Remain a Pope

The Daily Knight ^ | September 3, 2024 | David Martin

[ealgeone]

It’s the prots who are the “pope deniers”. Luther was one of the first and he was rightfully excommunicated.

Says the modern day Luther who has said more against the duly and legally elected pope of the rcc than any of the Reformers could have ever dreamed of.

[ealgeone]

LOL....the new luther isn’t a good chess player is he/she??

[ebb tide]

More false witness from an apostate from the Catholic Church.

[ebb tide]

They’re not attacks; they’re criticisms. And it’s because he’s not acting like a pope; he’s acting like a prot.

[ealgeone]

IIRC, didn't you and others warn the rcs about their now duly and legally elected pope?

And didn't the rcs tell you that you were wrong?

Kinda ironic now isn't it??

[ealgeone]

Hence a pope as a private person can profess heresy but could never make this profession while occupying the papal office.

Well, that's already happened numerous times in the history of the rcc.

The Marian dogmas come to mind as does the claim of papal infallibility.

Pope Urban II declaring a RC version of jihad as well.

I'd also add Unam Sanctam as well....yet certain romans like to ignore that one.

[ealgeone]

They’re not attacks; they’re criticisms.

Gotta remember this one in future discussions.

[metmom]

Many were warning the Catholics from the very beginning and we were castigated for it.

We were told he was misunderstood, mistranslated, misquoted, misinterpreted, we were *haters* and *anti-(fill in the blank)* and all other manner of accusations and names until the Catholics began to see the pattern for themselves.

Now we are heretics for not submitting to the pope and Catholicism they themselves are rejecting.

Ya just can’t win with some people.

[metmom]

So you don’t deny Francis as pope after all?

If you think he’s the actual valid pope, why do you attack him so much and call him a *Prot*?

[cgbg]

In the old days in Europe the real Pope raised an army and removed the anti-Pope.

Nowadays Catholics just sit there and take the abuse.

[ebb tide]

Ya just can’t win with some people.

Apostates and heretics will never win with God.

[metmom]

Pope Benedict did not offer a valid resignation, Pope is not a “shared” position, and this evil was not validly elected.

Got evidence of that or is your opinion good enough for that?

He's not duly elected because you say he's not?

[metmom]

I’m glad I belong to THE church which is THE body of Christ, and whose leader, Jesus, never changes, but is the same yesterday, today, and forever.

[ebb tide]

Your reading comprehension does not impress.

I said he acts like a prot.

[aspasia]

1.2 billion different interpretations of Catholicism and the Catechism of the Catholic church.

Multiply that by the diaspora of Protestant sects and you've come full circle.

[metmom]

You’re simply hair splitting.

[metmom]

It’s the prots who are the “pope deniers”.

Meanwhile, you continue to deny that the pope that your College of Cardinals voted in is the pope.

By your own definition, that makes you a *prot* since you've been protesting (objecting to vociferously) the direction the Catholic church has been going in for years.

[ebb tide]

By your own definition, that makes you a *prot* since you've been protesting (objecting to vociferously) the direction the Catholic church has been going in for years.

Poor, deluded metmom. It is you, not I, who has openly apostatized from the Catholic Church. It is you who has left the Catholic Church in the past "conciliar" years, not I. It is I who will continue to practice the Faith of my Fathers, not you.

I find it hilarious that you and your prot buddies are calling for my "excommunication" from the very Church that y'all reject in toto.

Just a bunch of hypocrites.

I truly think your attack on faithful Catholics is just a reflexive, but false, defense mechanism to justify your apostasy.

Let's see how well that works at your Final Judgement.

[metmom]

I never saw anyone calling for your ex-communication.

Could you provide the links to posts where they called for it?

[metmom]

Faithful Catholics?

With the attacks that you post daily on your pope and your hierarchy?

How is that being faithful when you actively undermine your church’s authority?