There is no evidence I've seen that Butler and President Lincoln even met in this time frame. The size of the fonts you use won't change that.
Walt
Collected Works of Abraham Lincoln, Roy P. Basler
APPENDIX II
Page 588
[1865]
Apr. 10. To Benjamin F. Butler, Hay for Lincoln, making appointment for ``tomorrow,''
ALS, DLC-Butler Papers
Then you are either blind or a liar. Hay's memo documents a meeting scheduled at EXACTLY the same time Butler claimed.