[AndrewC]

Truly, the Smokey Backroom issue should not have gotten out of the Smokey Backroom. But since it is here, the solution under the agreement is to not engage a disruptor.

That is not the point. Scarlet letters are the point.

[Alamo-Girl]

Thank you for your reply!

Scarlet letters are the point.

That happens to the issue of contention for which the vote was called. One initiative was that a troll should not be called a troll. The other was that a troll should be called a troll only after a polite warning, followed by a refusal to behave, followed by a notice not to engage, followed by a refusal to behave.

In the vote, the troll-calling provision won in a landslide. That of course means that the willing posters will make on-thread polite warnings and notices not to engage.

If this issue is intolerable to others, then it should be brought up in the review and voted on again. If it cannot wait, we can have a review even now if some of the willing from both sides can agree to an earlier review and a mediator.