Mr. Hanson appears to be applying the thesis he developed in his book, "Carnage and Culture:Landmark Battles in the Rise of Western Power" to the campaign in Iraq. His contention is that cultural distinctions are the most significant factor in deciding the outcome of military engagements. There are many holes in his theory, but certainly the Arab/American juxtaposition would give sound support to his theory.
However, it may be premature to write the history of the current conflict in Iraq. Lest we forget, since the "liberation" of Iraq in early April, U.S. forces have lost at least one soldier a day due to in theatre accidents or hostile fire. The possibility exists that the overall goal to create a stable and friendly Iraq may not be achieved, and then Mr. Hanson's thesis will need to be revisited.
Survey shows Iraqi people support US Presence
MEMRI ^ | May 28, 2003 | Al-Sharq Al-Awsat via Memri
SURVEY CONDUCTED BY THE IRAQI INSTITUTION FOR DEMOCRACY IN BAGHDAD SHOWED THAT MOST IRAQIS SUPPORT CONTINUED AMERICAN PRESENCE UNTIL DEMOCRATIC ELECTIONS ARE HELD IN IRAQ. (AL-SHARQ AL-AWSAT, LONDON 5/28/03)