[fightinJAG]

I think the judges' comments hurt Clay, especially Simon's continually carping on how he sounded "Broadway," which was intended to make everybody go "eeeewwwwwww."

[breakem]

and the ever popular "Rueben, the finals would not be complete without you."

I agree with Simon's comments 97.8% of the time. When he told Trynece she look like a drag queen after she did one of her best numbers and told Clay he was "horrible" after he sang Grease (I gave it a B). He was way over the top. Can be a good critic and not take such personal exaggerated shots.