Would you judge all ugly people to be ugly inside then?
Ugliness within is hardly EVER manifested on the outside, in my opinion. Why? Because people with true internal ugliness are sociopathic, without conscience, and they don't worry.
Physical beauty is absolutely NO indicator of goodness at all. None. Ted Bundy was a great looking guy--but a deadly socipathic killer. Most serial killers, most genocidal maniacs, most tyrants are good-looking people. Why shouldn't they be? They don't worry about anything. IMHO Equating ugliness with evil is a big mistake. Evil is a master of disguise.
No, that's why I specifically said "usually."
Physical beauty is absolutely NO indicator of goodness at all
I've seen many supposedly good looking women that I'm not the least bit attracted to turn out to be real b/tches. It shows in their eyes, and their foreheads. They could have perfect skin, teeth, bodies, the works. But there's something about them that makes them unattractive (and sometimes downright ugly) in my eyes. The answer: Their character. Their character manifests in their faces, and there's not a damn thing they can do about it. (This holds true for men too, obviously).