He needs to die in New York City.
Perhaps you would suport my modest proposal:
Interrogate him in Jordan, or Turkey, or Egypt. By all means, get what he knows.
Then, without a trial or tribunal, weld him into a steel cage.
Suspend the cage from the lower deck of the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, so it is clearly visible to all ships entering Upper New York Bay.
Leave him there.
Wait a thousand years, long enough so that nine times eleven generations of foreigners get to see what happens if you f*ck with America.