Well, let me ask... is lumping productive, in any case?
Here's what I've observed. An unpopular poster, with whom I often disagree both in style and substance, nailed a bullseye this time. Grover Norquist's links to radical Islam didn't come out of the blue, there have been warning signs for years. But we, all of us, dropped the ball, and when the feud between Gaffney and Norquist hit the fan, this poster in question got it right first.
The reason I don't like lumping is because you never really know whom you might find on your side of the fence on the next issue of the day. In this case, I think a great many on this forum have let their feelings for one poster color their understanding of this story.