Replies

10 to 15 years ago no one could imagine not living under the threat of nuclear destruction, and until recently the threat was largely gone. (I think the fear of TOTAL destruction is still in general gone). It's the same with terrorism (I hope) - some day THAT threat will be gone too.

I wonder where in the timeline of this article we shut the borders? And when will the internment of middle-easterners happen? As bad as the internment of the Japanese during WWII was, I wonder how many acts of sabotage, spying, etc. were stopped. (I guess one way to answer that would be to see how many Germans or Italians did bad stuff.)

>>As bad as the internment of the Japanese during WWII was, I wonder how many acts of sabotage, spying, etc. were stopped.

There is relatively recently available info that we knew of saboteur cells in the U.S. among Americans of Japanese heritage. We could not take out the cells without likely revealing that we had broken their communications codes, destroying this supremely valuable source of intelligence. Thus, the decision was made to intern everyone, and not just take out the cells.

See Magic: The Untold Story of U.S. Intelligence and the Evacuation of Japanese Residents from the West Coast during WW II.

From the review in the Amazon link above:

In late 1940 members of the U.S. Army Signal Intelligence Service broke Japan's highest level diplomatic code and then constructed a machine that was an analog of the one used by the Japanese. This allowed the U.S. to read Japan's diplomatic traffic from then until after the end of the war. Intelligence thus gained was cover named MAGIC because it seemed that only magicians could have produced it.

Among the decoded messages of 1941 were a number detailing espionage planning and operations involving Japanese-Americans along the West Coast. In February 1942 President Roosevelt authorized the evacuation of all persons of Japanese ancestry.

In 1983 a congressional commission, ignoring available declassified intelligence and ignorant of MAGIC revelations, concluded the President's action was the result of racism, war hysteria and lack of political will.

Now for the first time David D. Lowman, using MAGIC messages and declassified Army, Navy and FBI reports, presents the real reasons for the evacuation. As a former high level officer in the National Security Agency and a witness before congressional committees dealing with the evacuation he was uniquely qualified to tell this story. Those who could never quite believe the base motives attributed to our wartime leaders and our country will find Lowman's story compelling.

Important historical information for dealing with leftists screaming about the racism of Japanese internments in WWII.