It certainly would be, since evolution explains the interrelationships between species, not the origin of life.
All this waste of bandwidth says is abiogenesis doesn't occur on earth at present. As Homer Simpson would say, 'DOH!'
BTW, you need to look up the definition of an 'open system', wwhich requires exchange of matter, not merely energy. If I can make creationists one iota less ignorant of basic scientific principles, I'm doing my job..