[Sid Rich]

1. I wasn't discussing airline safety, but since you've deflected the issue to that, I do think allowing citizens to carry firearms on board airplanes is a good idea.

2. Back to the point, advising US citizens of appropriate actions to take in the event of a bio-chem attack is a proper role of government in my opinion. The use of duct tape and plastic sheeting to secure a room against bio-chem agents, as well as stockpiling food is not absurd...at least according to the Israeli government, who probably know a thing or twenty about the issue.

From the BBC today, "Later Mr Yaron told Israel Radio that citizens should start to follow instructions in a recently-distributed emergency handbook that explains how to seal rooms against chemical or biological attack.

The handbook also advises them to stock up on food, water, batteries and first aid kits.

"The chance that something will happen here is very low but we have to prepare for all possibilities," he said.

Israel faces possible chemical attack

Hardware shops in Israel have reported heavy demand for plastic wrap and heavy-duty tape to seal rooms, the Reuters news agency said."

[JohnGalt]

Perhaps, then we have had a misunderstanding. I was using the 'duct tape versus firearm' comparison for effect, not making a policy recommendation. No true American household is without duct tape (and WD-40) to begin with.

I wholeheartedly agree that state governments should spend more time on civil defense rather than social engineering. However, lets agree, that creating a false sense of security by defining preparedness with the purchase of batteries, duct tape, plastic wrap, and canned food is worse than being frank with the American people.