[go star go]

The question is not whether the clone is human but whether this human clone will be infused with a soul.

What would be the difference? Are you saying a human can exist without a soul?

[Polycarp]

Are you saying a human can exist without a soul?

I don't know! This is part of the whole clone question.

Does it have a soul? Will God allow His Natural Law to be so violated by our arrogance and pride that human clones come into existence? If so, will He infuse such a "monster" with a human soul? If not, will it even be able to "live"?

These are the questions being asked.

Personally, I do not think God will permit man to commit this catastrophy.

Even if He does, I do not think He is bound by His Natural Law to infuse the soul into human flesh created in this fashion.

If a clone is created, and God does not infuse it with a soul, will it, can it, evenLIVE?

I don't know...I speak as a Catholic but certainly not for Catholicism.

[sweetliberty]

"Are you saying a human can exist without a soul?"

What about zombies?