Can someone explain to me how a gun that was stolen in a burglary from a gun store was then sold on-paper to Mr Sylvester?
I can see how the cops could've matched ballistics once the rifle was recovered, but not before (at least in 1994)since I don't think NY was tracking the ballistic record of longarms sold in the state back then.
Probably the burglar was caught and told who he sold the rifle to!