Islamaniacs are big believers in bearing guns and anti-abortion. So choosing between them and Diane Feinstein would certainly be distressing but I would have to go with D.F. since she is not trying to kill me now.
But I agree in general with your drift.
The comparison is a non-starter. D.F. and the Islamics are both trying to destroy our liberty, one much quicker thaan the other, but both of them sure ... so the obvious qualification is that the individual MUST not be a tyrannt and must support the liberty espoused by the founders and the constitution that defines it. Neither of your options do that and I am sorry if that point was not clear.
I would vote for neither and would set my self in a place best apt to influence and swing things the right way (ie. as I am in Idaho) ... and if there was no other recourse, would have to defer to the same option and course our founders took.