I have here a large can of fresh, unopened Virginia peanuts. Would you like them, sir??
I'm the final arbiter of this matter & to hell with those gutless old men & the old bag on the SCOTUS.
"...if neither Mudboy Slim's team nor the Sultan's team make it to the playoffs, then it's a tie. The wager is who goes further in the playoffs.
Isn't that so, oh great and powerful and wise judge?"
You forgot omnipotent, but...OK.
Yes, I believe that that is the *crux* of the wager & I shall rule (~in your favor) accordingly. (so you'd better be a regular praying mantis these two tie, buster.)
...better peanuts than The Peanut Shop of Williamsburg, huh? ;^)