Replies

Well that would depend on where there origins were. If they are immigrants of some kind who have been naturalized then i would suggest that they go back to where they came from. If the were born here then deporting is not an option per se. Though in some instances they might be sent back to their parents nation of origin. As for american citizens born and bred in the USA who are muslim. Those individuals obviously cant be deported anywhere but I think that it is reasonable to be wary and watchful of their behavior.

Keep in mind I am not even speaking of this as an alternative as of this moment. I am speaking of this as a reality if terrorists should ever blow up nuclear weapons in say New York city or Washington. In reality I fear should that occur then the situation will actually be much worse. People would probably be killing muslims in the streets at that point.

That is actually exactly what my point is. Much of this kind of senselessness could be averted if we were to do the right things now. The reality is that we are at war. They have already killed an equivilant of 5% of the number of American lives lost in Vietnam. They have openly declared their intent to destroy us. There is a history 1400 years long of Islamic enmity toward the non muslim world. There own sacred writing call for this as a moral imperative. They have already launched attacks against us and continue to plan on doing so.

There is a mountain of evidence conveniently ignored that most of these countries directly supply terrorists group and yet we call them our friends. We vasilate and prevaricate when we should be sending a clear message. That further attacks against us will be met with the gravest of consequences. Iraq should be made an example of. Not out of any blood lust or religious hatred towards Muslims. I dont "hate" muslims. But neither will I suffer them to kill me and destroy my country or bring harm to my loved ones. Their religion however does in fact prescribe dominion and conquest, no matter who attempts to deny it...and I am not of the mind to give it to them.

If people in your position think I am speaking out of some kind of religious fervor against muslims you could not be more wrong. My religion does not call for conquest and global domination. It is not "religion" that makes me call for more direct action. It is self preservation.

I have already stated my reasoning for this. Now I would ask you to give a more directed argument against that.

You seem to disagree but I have to say that asking me where I would deport a million muslims to does not address the central issue of my argument.

As you said..lets have a debate..but in order to debate you you have to have a clear position. I think I have stated mine fairly succintly and no where in my argument does being a chrinstian anter into the logic of it.