I doubt it, I don't think a self-respecting scientist (who values his career) would touch it with someone elses sliderule.
However, pure review does not prove something is right, or wrong for that matter. Scienctific opinion is wrought with human flaws, mainly ego. The Fuser that Physicist refered to is an excellent example.
108 posted on 08/01/2002 7:04:12 AM PDT by Dead Dog