LBB claimed circles were not elipses, and that the planets had "wildly eliptical" orbits. In reality the orbits have very low eliptical values and can be considered as circles for many calculations -- with the exceptions of Mercury and Pluto. Remember, this all came about because of the discussion on your theory that the Earth orbited Saturn before moving into its current position, and how it was pointed out that such a move would result in a highly eliptical orbit rather than a near circular one.