To: Viva Le Dissention
Strike one: You lied about your political and ideological affiliations.
Strike two: You made me look up a nongermane case.
Want to go for strike three?
As to the non-sequitur you mentioned about the hitching post:
- I am not sure why you mentioned Scalia (unless you wanted to be ad hominem), because Thomas wrote the dissent, Scalia and Rhenquist joined.
- I scanned the dissent. It's an interesting read and a careful and delicate treating of the facts, but the bottom line is: They sued the wrong guys. God forbid Thomas, Scalia and Rhenquist pay attention to the actual case at hand instead of throwing their judicial weight around.
To: AmishDude
I mentioned Scalia because he thought it was perfectly acceptable to chain a prisoner to a hitching post. I don't know why you're reading more into it than what it is.
#2, I never lied about my political affiliations. I said I am ultra-conservative. That's totally true. I've voted straight libertarian in every election I've ever voted in, with the exception of a a friend of mine who was running for Governor on the Republican ticket and a friend of mine who is a judge, a Democrat.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson