To: John Jamieson
I know judges never put number on it, but what error rate should the jury shoot for: 1 in ten, 1 in hundred, or 1 in thousand wrong convictions? If you are willing to accept 1 in ten then the jury could be told let him go "only if there is overwelling doubt". One in 100 might require "resonable doubt" and one in a thousand might "any doubt at all". I personally think our jury system probably does operate at about 1 in 100 innocent convictions. What do think?
To: John Jamieson
"
I know judges never put number on it, but what error rate should the jury shoot for: 1 in ten, 1 in hundred, or 1 in thousand wrong convictions? If you are willing to accept 1 in ten then the jury could be told let him go "only if there is overwelling doubt". One in 100 might require "resonable doubt" and one in a thousand might "any doubt at all". I personally think our jury system probably does operate at about 1 in 100 innocent convictions. What do think? "If you're asking how many times the jury should convict the wrong guy....Zero!!! But, tell me do we allow for human error in the only justice system we know? If so how?
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson