A "respectable critique" would be wasted on most of the pro-Dawkins groupies here. Why take the trouble of crafting a detailed, careful analysis and posting it only to have them unzip and urinate on it?
Smash-mouth graffiti--not detailed, fine art--is generally all that these zealots deserve.
There is a time and place for everything. This is neither the time nor place.
BTTT :^)