I would have given Creationism a fair shake, until I saw the people who supported it, and how they supported it.
Yep. The old "Ugly Creationist" problem: testimony that many of the effects of faith are not pretty or much of a good idea.
This has always been problematic for me. I "feel" that a Creator exists, but instead of reasoned and persuasive arguments, I have been accosted by individuals who claim I will go to hell simply for being a scientist. As representatives of Jesus Christ, they fall far short of the love He preached and demonstrated...for not once in the accounts of His life did Jesus ever respond with such vitriol. Instead, Jesus seemed to enjoy speaking with those who searched for answers to difficult questions. Sadly, this attitude is painfully absent from today's evangelism.