I won't get into his issues because that is his stuff to work out, and this is my account, not his. But I will post his pace of mind at reading the header of this thread where you explain who gets the bullet and why. (He claims never to have been E mailed as to what he did wrong.)
There is not any wiggle room to complain much about how you run your private forum. It is your party, and as host of said party, you can show anyone the door who you feel is detracting from it.
Do you make mistakes and sometime amputate a good hearted soul who doesn't warrant it? No doubt you do; but only because you are human and can only do the best you can. Just like the rest of us mortals. Claiming this happens broadly, and that this is a justification to lash out at Free Republic is foolish at best.
On the balance you do an excellent job, and it is clear you care about this place and pour your heart and soul into it. I thank you and wish you my best. Surprisingly enough, my non-posting friend feels mostly the same way, and like you alot s well.
I am glad I found this forum, and I wish it and it's founder a long and prosperous life.