[Phantom Lord]

I was the first poster to speak out that the sisters story didnt add up way back on the original 'breaking' thread of this girls 'kidnapping'.

I have taken many a flame for this. I still stand by my contention that the sisters story is a fabrication by either herself, or feed to her by her missing sister.

[Utah Girl]

Except that child forensic interviewers say that Mary Catherine's story has remained consistent. New details emerge, but the overall story remains and has remained the same. I read in the SL Tribune one psychologist who said that there wasn't enough time to drill that kind of a story into a nine year old's head. Usually if the story is a lie, it falls apart rather quickly, and Mary Catherine's has not.

[TheDon]

I was the first poster to speak out that the sisters story didnt add up way back on the original 'breaking' thread of this girls 'kidnapping'.

Perhaps not as reported by the media anyway.