Translation: "Anyone who disagrees with my interpretation is accusing the Pope of errors in Development of doctrine or imposing novelties."
That is crazy. This isn't about MY interpretation vs yours or Scalia's, or Sinkspur's. This is about the Pope's Encyclical, Doctrine taught in the Universal Catechism. This is about the Pope's explanation of the Development of Doctrine concerning Capital Punishment and it is in Evangelium Vitae.
I know you think your arguement is with me over my (non-existent) "question begging" but the arguement, such as it is, is between those who reject this Pope's Doctrinal Teaching and the Pope. It really isn't an "arguement." What it is is an attempt to rationalise opposition to the Magisterium.