The idea that we cannot really know and we will just have to take the word of each seminarian for it is how we got into this mess in the first place.Well, how do we know who is gay and who is not?
You can't know. There are no tests which screen for homosexuality.
Do seminary boards just guess?
Seminary boards? What are you talking about? Try Diocese Vocational Director. How can you be so consistently out of touch. Your claim of being Catholic is falling flat, pal.
Our new Vocational Director in Tucson is a Gay Priest. He/she/it decides who goes to the seminary and who is denied.
Looks like our "progressive" bishop and coadjutor are right on the cutting edge of solving the sexual scandal in the Church. (/sarcasm)