Posted on 04/10/2002 4:03:51 PM PDT by Revolting cat!
The sky won't fall in Araby. Entrenched regimes, which have mastered precious little save the art of staying in power, will not be stampeded by the crowds who chant in support of Yasser Arafat. This is not a "crisis" of American foreign policy playing out in Ramallah, and reverberating in Amman, Cairo, and Beirut.
Instead of being alarmed, we should keep our focus on the campaign against terror. We do the Arabs no favor if we pick up the false trail of Arafat, and let the new war against terror be trumped by old Arab obsessions with Palestine.
The claim that there is "disarray" in American foreign policy -- made by former national security adviser Zbigniew Brzezinski, who should know a thing or two about disarray -- is fatuous. There is no conceivable American diplomacy on the Palestinian question that could still the furies of the jihadists. The policy of the Bush administration has been on the mark. Assertive and unyielding, it has pursued the monumental task of taking on the culture of terror -- its infrastructure, its fronts, the whole intellectual and psychological edifice that justifies terror by virtue of a Palestinian alibi.
Beyond Ramallah
Care should be exercised as we rush in to broker cease-fires: There is a whole Arab and Islamic world beyond Nablus and Arafat's compound in Ramallah. Primacy must still belong to the larger struggle to rid the Arab world of its malignancies, to thwart the jihadists and those who would cede them political ground.
Arafat's game is transparent: He wishes to overwhelm Operation Enduring Freedom with his own war against Israel. And for his troubles, he seeks the rewards of days past. There shall come his way financial backing from Iraq and the Gulf states. (A commercial street in Baghdad has just been named for him.) And there shall be offered him and his people the false promise that the Arabs have offered Palestinians ever since the unfolding of their encounter with Zionism: that the cavalry is on its way, that demonstrators are about to set the world ablaze and come to the rescue of Palestine.
The sad truth of history is that the Palestinians opted for pragmatism just once -- when they broke with Arab legends and made peace at Oslo. Then, they returned to the world of nations, and secured a political turf of their own. The new storm is but a return to the old ways.
In vast swaths of the Arab world, people know the truth of their condition but cannot utter it. Terror silences them. There is no deliverance, they know, if the cult of "martyrdom" is sanctified. There are embattled people who are eager for their world to be done with the furies of Islamism. The American victory in Afghanistan, and the promise that this new war has grander moral ambitions than the war that was fought against Iraq a decade ago, emboldened Arabs keen to retrieve the ground that religious and political radicalism had conquered. There is hope that there might be educational reform, and that radical preachers might be tamed.
The Arab regimes that tell us that they are about to fall are conceding their own illegitimacy. The Arabs should be granted no special waiver from the imperatives of political reform -- especially not by an America with its own quest for a just retribution against terror. For the good part of a decade, American policy averted its gaze from the malignant anti-Americanism at play in Arab lands, in pursuit of an Israeli-Palestinian settlement. An American "Balfour Declaration" was granted the Palestinians by President Clinton, but the anti-American terror paid that diplomacy no heed.
Yet we should know that there is quiet approval in Arab lands -- among decent men and women who harbor no illusions about warlords and preachers of zealotry -- of America's campaign against terror. Our pundits here or in Europe may have been troubled by the "axis of evil" remarks of President Bush, but there were many Arabs who savored the clarity.
The crowds which have taken to Arab streets ought to be viewed with skepticism. The mind and the mood of a culture are difficult things to read. For all the public fury, a measure of introspection settled on the Arabs after Sept. 11: Those were their sons who had flown into those towers, those are their radical children on the run the world over. Psychologically, the protests over the troubles in Israel and the West Bank were an opportunity to escape the scathing judgments of others. If everyone is guilty, no one is guilty: Why dwell on the terror of Mohammed Atta when there are other terrors?
No Settlement
We can't impose a "settlement" of the Israeli-Palestinian struggle: That would be hubris. And we can't fall for the myth that Palestine is what ails Egypt, for example, or Iraq, and that al Qaeda's adherents are driven also by the passions of Palestine. We can't hold our own war hostage to Arafat's campaign of terror. That world is what it is, and we shall not be given a warrant for a strike against Iraq, or a reprieve from anti-Americanism, by accommodating Arafat or the al Aqsa Martyrs' Brigade.
There is a truth we should know: In the Arab world that beckons American power and hectors it at the same time, there are people terrified that the young men -- and now young women -- of terror may yet prevail. In the aftermath of victory in Afghanistan, these people saw prospects of deliverance. We owe them and ourselves fidelity to this new campaign. We need to reiterate to them that the truth of this campaign against terror holds in Netanya and Kabul, and that the way out of political ruin is an Arab break, once and for all, with the false consolations of terror.
Mr. Ajami, a professor at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies, is the author of "The Dream Palace of the Arabs" (Vintage, 1999).
If you want on or off me Israel/MidEast ping list please let me know. Via Freepmail is best way.............
the author may have a point... but we'd not know. there may
well be the silent masses of arabs hoping for better than they've seen, and
maybe even deliverance. but in the meantime, they're killing us.
If Arafat is not taken care of immediately, then he'll be taken care of on our swing out of Iraq. One way or the other, Arafat is on borrowed time. No, we're not going to kill him, that's what he wants. Instead we'll send him off into exile to live out what's left of his life in solitude.
Yep, even if Palestine and Israel were best buddies, these places would still be cesspools in need of a political and cultural revolution.
Adjami is on the mark. Arafat will be reduced to an irrlevancy when Saddam is overthrown. The raw demonstration of American power will impress every Arab in every Arab Street.
Arafat is a fool if he thinks he can stop the Iraqi operation. But unlike his money, a fool and his beliefs are not easily parted.
Be Seeing You,
Chris
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.