[riley1992]

If your religious beliefs (or more applicable to this situation, your openly declared lack of religious beliefs) will end up raising the costs of a business, it is completely appropriate for them to charge you more than other people.

They should be able to show proof of this first then. In other words, it is concretely documented that certain cars are more prone to theft, therefore, the premium on them is going to be higher. The insurance company would be making a baseless assumption based on what for raising the premium for the Atheist plate?

[timm22]

They should be able to show proof of this first then. In other words, it is concretely documented that certain cars are more prone to theft, therefore, the premium on them is going to be higher.

Or what about this- if you don't like the insurance company's policies, you take your business elsewhere? Why don't we just let the company decide what it wants to do and how it wants to do it?

[CharacterCounts]

A private company should be able to charge whatever it wants to anyone it wants for any reason it wants.

I have always found it ironic that the same federal government that the Bill of Rights was intended to restrict follows the Constitution less and less while it forces the Constituion on individuals and companies (both of whom were never intended to be covered).